Funny, Scary, Dead: Negative Depictions of Male Homosexuality in American Advertising

Kathleen O'Leary; Blaine J. Branchik

doi:10.1108/JHRM-07-2015-0027

Funny, Scary, Dead: Negative Depictions of Male Homosexuality in American Advertising

Kathleen O'Leary
, Blaine J. Branchik

Research output: Contribution to journal › Article › peer-review

4 Scopus citations

Abstract

<p> <h5> Purpose </h5></p><p> The purpose of this study is to examine negative depictions of male homosexuality in US print and video advertising during the twentieth and early twenty-first centuries. It answers three research questions: What sorts of negative depictions of homosexuality are presented? How, if at all, have pejorative depictions of gay men evolved in the past 100 years? and Why have they changed? <h5> Design/methodology/approach </h5></p><p> The authors specify eight depictions of negative imagery in advertising and, using content analysis, assess 88 print and video advertisements featuring 133 depictions culled from a large sample. <h5> Findings </h5></p><p> Analysis reveals that, once rare, there has been a rapid expansion of negative gay imagery in advertisements beginning in 2000, even as gays are gain increasing acceptance and visibility. Typical advertisement depictions have evolved from men dressed as woman early in the twentieth century to men reacting with fear, revulsion or even violence to concerns that they might be gay or be subject to homosexual advances. <h5> Research limitations/implications </h5></p><p> Given the paucity of available imagery, data collection was opportunistic and resulted in a relatively small sample. <h5> Practical implications </h5></p><p> Practitioners can benefit from explication of how various audiences can view certain advertisement depictions of gay men as insulting or threatening. They can then become more attuned to the impact of negative minority depictions in general. <h5> Social implications </h5></p><p> Society can benefit from heightened awareness of the impact imagery can have on minority or marginalized groups. Results further illustrate society’s evolving and ambivalent views on homosexuality, the visibility of gay imagery in media in general and changing notions of manhood and masculinity. <h5> Originality/value </h5></p><p> The authors are aware of no other study that specifically categorizes and assesses negative depictions of gay advertisement imagery.</p>

Original language	American English
Journal	Journal of Historical Research in Marketing
Volume	8
DOIs	https://doi.org/10.1108/JHRM-07-2015-0027
State	Published - Jan 1 2016

Keywords

Advertising appeals
Advertising history
Gay men
Homosexuals
Minority ad images

Disciplines

Business

Access to Document

10.1108/JHRM-07-2015-0027License: Unspecified

Cite this

@article{fb387a9d3bf04775a90282c7d7f53906,

title = "Funny, Scary, Dead: Negative Depictions of Male Homosexuality in American Advertising",

abstract = " Purpose The purpose of this study is to examine negative depictions of male homosexuality in US print and video advertising during the twentieth and early twenty-first centuries. It answers three research questions: What sorts of negative depictions of homosexuality are presented? How, if at all, have pejorative depictions of gay men evolved in the past 100 years? and Why have they changed? Design/methodology/approach The authors specify eight depictions of negative imagery in advertising and, using content analysis, assess 88 print and video advertisements featuring 133 depictions culled from a large sample. Findings Analysis reveals that, once rare, there has been a rapid expansion of negative gay imagery in advertisements beginning in 2000, even as gays are gain increasing acceptance and visibility. Typical advertisement depictions have evolved from men dressed as woman early in the twentieth century to men reacting with fear, revulsion or even violence to concerns that they might be gay or be subject to homosexual advances. Research limitations/implications Given the paucity of available imagery, data collection was opportunistic and resulted in a relatively small sample. Practical implications Practitioners can benefit from explication of how various audiences can view certain advertisement depictions of gay men as insulting or threatening. They can then become more attuned to the impact of negative minority depictions in general. Social implications Society can benefit from heightened awareness of the impact imagery can have on minority or marginalized groups. Results further illustrate society\’s evolving and ambivalent views on homosexuality, the visibility of gay imagery in media in general and changing notions of manhood and masculinity. Originality/value The authors are aware of no other study that specifically categorizes and assesses negative depictions of gay advertisement imagery.",

keywords = "Advertising appeals, Advertising history, Gay men, Homosexuals, Minority ad images",

author = "Kathleen O'Leary and Branchik, \{Blaine J.\}",

year = "2016",

month = jan,

day = "1",

doi = "10.1108/JHRM-07-2015-0027",

language = "American English",

volume = "8",

journal = "Journal of Historical Research in Marketing",

issn = "1755-750X",

publisher = "Emerald Group Publishing Ltd.",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Funny, Scary, Dead: Negative Depictions of Male Homosexuality in American Advertising

AU - O'Leary, Kathleen

AU - Branchik, Blaine J.

PY - 2016/1/1

Y1 - 2016/1/1

N2 - Purpose The purpose of this study is to examine negative depictions of male homosexuality in US print and video advertising during the twentieth and early twenty-first centuries. It answers three research questions: What sorts of negative depictions of homosexuality are presented? How, if at all, have pejorative depictions of gay men evolved in the past 100 years? and Why have they changed? Design/methodology/approach The authors specify eight depictions of negative imagery in advertising and, using content analysis, assess 88 print and video advertisements featuring 133 depictions culled from a large sample. Findings Analysis reveals that, once rare, there has been a rapid expansion of negative gay imagery in advertisements beginning in 2000, even as gays are gain increasing acceptance and visibility. Typical advertisement depictions have evolved from men dressed as woman early in the twentieth century to men reacting with fear, revulsion or even violence to concerns that they might be gay or be subject to homosexual advances. Research limitations/implications Given the paucity of available imagery, data collection was opportunistic and resulted in a relatively small sample. Practical implications Practitioners can benefit from explication of how various audiences can view certain advertisement depictions of gay men as insulting or threatening. They can then become more attuned to the impact of negative minority depictions in general. Social implications Society can benefit from heightened awareness of the impact imagery can have on minority or marginalized groups. Results further illustrate society’s evolving and ambivalent views on homosexuality, the visibility of gay imagery in media in general and changing notions of manhood and masculinity. Originality/value The authors are aware of no other study that specifically categorizes and assesses negative depictions of gay advertisement imagery.

AB - Purpose The purpose of this study is to examine negative depictions of male homosexuality in US print and video advertising during the twentieth and early twenty-first centuries. It answers three research questions: What sorts of negative depictions of homosexuality are presented? How, if at all, have pejorative depictions of gay men evolved in the past 100 years? and Why have they changed? Design/methodology/approach The authors specify eight depictions of negative imagery in advertising and, using content analysis, assess 88 print and video advertisements featuring 133 depictions culled from a large sample. Findings Analysis reveals that, once rare, there has been a rapid expansion of negative gay imagery in advertisements beginning in 2000, even as gays are gain increasing acceptance and visibility. Typical advertisement depictions have evolved from men dressed as woman early in the twentieth century to men reacting with fear, revulsion or even violence to concerns that they might be gay or be subject to homosexual advances. Research limitations/implications Given the paucity of available imagery, data collection was opportunistic and resulted in a relatively small sample. Practical implications Practitioners can benefit from explication of how various audiences can view certain advertisement depictions of gay men as insulting or threatening. They can then become more attuned to the impact of negative minority depictions in general. Social implications Society can benefit from heightened awareness of the impact imagery can have on minority or marginalized groups. Results further illustrate society’s evolving and ambivalent views on homosexuality, the visibility of gay imagery in media in general and changing notions of manhood and masculinity. Originality/value The authors are aware of no other study that specifically categorizes and assesses negative depictions of gay advertisement imagery.

KW - Advertising appeals

KW - Advertising history

KW - Gay men

KW - Homosexuals

KW - Minority ad images

UR - https://nsuworks.nova.edu/hcbe_facarticles/644

U2 - 10.1108/JHRM-07-2015-0027

DO - 10.1108/JHRM-07-2015-0027

M3 - Article

SN - 1755-750X

VL - 8

JO - Journal of Historical Research in Marketing

JF - Journal of Historical Research in Marketing

ER -

Funny, Scary, Dead: Negative Depictions of Male Homosexuality in American Advertising

Abstract

Keywords

Disciplines

Access to Document

Other files and links

Fingerprint

Cite this